Is a Heat Pump Cheaper Than Propane in Illinois? Yes, by an Estimated $125 to $470 a Year
Yes. At 2026 prices, a heat pump heats an Illinois home for roughly half to three-quarters of what propane costs, depending on your utility. Illinois residential propane averaged $1.829 a gallon before taxes on October 5, 2026, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. That's about $2.11 per 100,000 Btu of heat in a 95 percent furnace. A heat pump delivers the same heat for about $1.05 on Ameren Illinois' winter tier above 800 kWh and about $1.30 on ComEd's electric space heat class. For a home that burns about 530 gallons a winter for heat, my estimate is $290 to $470 a year saved on Ameren or ComEd's space heat class, and $125 to $270 on ComEd's standard class.
That's the opposite of what I told natural gas customers last month. In my heat pump vs gas furnace breakdown, gas still won per unit of heat everywhere in the state. Propane is a different animal. A gallon carries less heat than most people assume, and at last winter's prices a unit of propane heat cost roughly three times what the same heat from Nicor gas did.
Key facts: propane and electric heat in Illinois, fall 2026
| Line | Figure | In effect |
|---|---|---|
| Illinois residential propane | $1.829/gal, before taxes (vs $1.724 a year earlier) | Week of Oct 5, 2026; EIA weekly survey |
| Last winter's Illinois propane average | About $1.90/gal; peak $2.204 | Oct 2025 – Mar 2026; peak week of Feb 9, 2026 |
| Average Midwest propane home, this winter | 529 gal for heat + 112 gal other uses; $2.036/gal | Nov 2026 – Mar 2027 forecast; EIA, Oct 2026 |
| Heat in a gallon of propane | 91,452 Btu (1 kWh = 3,412 Btu) | EIA conversion |
| Ameren Illinois electric, winter tiers (est.) | About 15.0¢/kWh first 800 kWh, 10.7¢ above | Oct 2026 – May 2027 supply; delivery rises slightly with January 2027 bills |
| ComEd supply + delivery (est.) | About 13.3¢/kWh space heat class, 16.4¢ standard | 10.103¢ Price to Compare Oct 2026 – May 2027; delivery from April 2026 bills |
| Ameren propane-to-electric help | Heat pump and appliances at little to no cost, income-qualified | Ameren HEIQ initiative, current page |
| Ameren heat pump discount | $900 ducted, $630 ductless | Instant Incentives, Ameren electric customers |
| Federal 25C heat pump tax credit | Ended for property placed in service after Dec 31, 2025 | IRS, OBBB FAQ |
Electric figures add each utility's supply, transmission and per-kWh delivery charges, and leave out taxes and the smaller riders. EIA's weekly propane prices exclude taxes too.
The cost per unit of heat, side by side
A furnace and a heat pump sell you the same product, so compare them on the same unit. I use 100,000 Btu, which is one therm. A gallon of propane holds 91,452 Btu, so a therm of fuel at $1.829 a gallon costs $2.00. A 95 percent furnace loses a little up the vent, which brings it to about $2.11 of heat.
A heat pump moves heat rather than burning anything. Its efficiency is its coefficient of performance, or COP. At a COP of 3, it makes three units of heat from one unit of electricity, so a therm of heat takes about 9.8 kWh.
| Heating source | Cost per 100,000 Btu of heat (est.) |
|---|---|
| Propane, 95% furnace, $1.829 (Oct 5, 2026) | ~$2.11 |
| Propane, 95% furnace, $1.90 (last winter's average) | ~$2.19 |
| Propane, 95% furnace, $2.204 (Feb 9, 2026 peak) | ~$2.54 |
| Propane, 80% furnace, $1.829 | ~$2.50 |
| Heat pump, COP 3, Ameren above 800 kWh (10.7¢) | ~$1.05 |
| Heat pump, COP 3, ComEd space heat class (13.3¢) | ~$1.30 |
| Heat pump, COP 3, ComEd standard class (16.4¢) | ~$1.60 |
| Heat pump, COP 1.9 (a 0–5°F night), Ameren above 800 kWh | ~$1.65 |
| Electric baseboard, Ameren above 800 kWh | ~$3.14 |
Look at the second-to-last line. Even on a near-zero night, when a cold-climate heat pump's efficiency sags, it still beats a brand-new propane furnace on Ameren's upper winter tier. Turn the math around and you get the break-even COP, the efficiency a heat pump needs just to tie propane: about 1.5 on Ameren above 800 kWh, 1.85 on ComEd's space heat class and 2.3 on ComEd's standard class. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate label requires at least 1.75 at 5°F, and the Department of Energy's cold-climate field study measured a median of 1.9 between 0°F and 5°F.
If your furnace is an older 80 percent unit, propane looks worse still, and the break-even falls to about 1.25 on Ameren.
What it means for a year's heating bill
The EIA forecasts the average Midwest propane home will burn about 529 gallons for space heat this winter. Assuming a 95 percent furnace, that's about 46 million Btu of delivered heat. A heat pump needs roughly 4,500 to 5,400 kWh to match it, at a season-average COP of 3.0 to 2.5. I priced the propane at last winter's Illinois average of about $1.90, or $1,007 for the heating gallons.
| Territory | Propane heat (529 gal) | Heat pump, COP 2.5 / 3.0 | Estimated yearly savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ameren Illinois electric (blended 12¢) | $1,007 | $646 / $539 | ~$360 to $470 |
| ComEd, space heat class (13.3¢) | $1,007 | $716 / $597 | ~$290 to $410 |
| ComEd, standard class (16.4¢) | $1,007 | $883 / $736 | ~$125 to $270 |
The Ameren line uses a blended 12¢ because most heating kilowatt-hours in an Ameren home fall above the 800 kWh winter tier. ComEd's space heat class has a second payoff. A home that heats entirely with electricity is billed the lower delivery charge on every kilowatt-hour, which I estimated at roughly $211 a year for a house using 8,000 kWh on everything else. The catch is that ComEd requires the backup heat to be electric too. I explained the rules in the ComEd electric space heat rate.
My numbers come in under RMI's. Its March 2026 Illinois analysis put average savings for propane homes at about $930 a year. Its assumptions differ from mine, and I'd rather show you the conservative version you can check against your own delivery tickets.
One honest caveat for southern Illinois: a lot of propane homes down there buy electricity from a rural electric cooperative, not Ameren. Co-op rates are set differently, so run the math with your own bill before you trust my Ameren column.
How Illinois propane prices have moved
Propane is priced week to week, and it almost always climbs as the season goes on. Here's the first fall reading and the winter peak for the last five heating seasons, from the EIA's weekly Illinois survey.
| Heating season | First October price | Winter peak |
|---|---|---|
| 2021–22 | $2.122 (Oct 4) | $2.504 (Mar 14, 2022) |
| 2022–23 | $2.061 (Oct 3) | $2.144 (Jan–Feb 2023) |
| 2023–24 | $1.766 (Oct 2) | $1.946 (Feb 12, 2024) |
| 2024–25 | $1.734 (Oct 7) | $2.076 (Feb 24, 2025) |
| 2025–26 | $1.724 (Oct 6) | $2.204 (Feb 9, 2026) |
| 2026–27 | $1.829 (Oct 5) | — |
This fall opened about 6 percent above last fall. The EIA's Midwest forecast calls for a season average about 3 percent below last winter's, but Illinois started the season higher than it did a year ago, so don't count on a cheaper winter. My take: if you're staying on propane this winter, fill the tank early or ask your dealer about a fixed-price contract, and compare it against what they'd charge on a will-call delivery in February.
Keep the propane furnace as backup? Often, yes
With natural gas, I tell people a hybrid heat pump is mostly an air-conditioning upgrade. With propane, it's a real bill cut, because the heat pump wins at almost every outdoor temperature.
On Ameren, a heat pump only needs a COP of about 1.5 to beat propane, so it should carry the house through nearly all of winter. The furnace sits there for the worst cold snap or a breakdown. That also covers you if the power goes out, as long as the furnace blower has backup power. I compared the backup options in generator vs home battery for an Illinois winter outage.
On ComEd, a propane furnace as backup keeps the house in the standard delivery class, where the break-even is about 2.3. Ask the installer to set the switchover temperature where your unit's efficiency drops near that point. Every model's spec sheet lists its efficiency at different outdoor temperatures.
Either way, size the heat pump with a room-by-room load calculation. An undersized unit hands the coldest hours to electric backup strips, which run at a COP of 1, and on ComEd's standard class that's about $4.81 per 100,000 Btu, the most expensive heat on the chart.
Help paying for the switch
The federal 25C credit that covered 30 percent of a heat pump is gone for anything placed in service after December 31, 2025. Here's what's left:
- Ameren Illinois, Switch from Propane to Electric. Through its Home Efficiency Income Qualified initiative, Ameren offers income-qualified, propane-heated single-family homes a free home energy assessment. Qualifying homes may get an air source heat pump, a heat pump water heater, an induction stove and an electric dryer at little to no cost. You must be an Ameren Illinois residential electric customer and meet income limits based on household size and location. Ameren says you'll get a report on whether the switch should lower your bill before anything is installed.
- Ameren Instant Incentives. Open to Ameren Illinois electric customers with no income test listed: $900 off a ducted air source heat pump rated at least 15.2 SEER2 and 8.1 HSPF2, and $630 off a ductless unit.
- ComEd. Its September 2025 home energy customer guide lists heat pump discounts up to $2,000 through ComEd heat pump-trained contractors. Ask for the current 2026 amount in writing.
- Illinois HEAR. The federally funded electrification rebate for low-income households still hasn't launched. Illinois EPA says its application hasn't been processed by the Department of Energy, and it won't pay rebates retroactively.
If heating bills are already a stretch, LIHEAP helps propane households too. DCEO lets households with less than 25 percent left in their propane tank apply in the early window that opened October 1, 2026, and other income-eligible households can apply starting November 1. I listed the income limits in Illinois electric bill help and income limits.
Where solar fits
Switching off propane moves the whole heating load onto your electric meter, roughly 4,500 to 5,400 kWh a year, nearly all of it from November through March. That's when Illinois panels produce the least. I charted the drop in how Illinois solar production falls in fall and winter.
I'd rather you hear that from me now than discover it on a January bill. Solar on an all-electric farmhouse earns most of its keep from April through September. Over a full year, though, it can offset a real share of the bigger bill. With a $0-down lease, the power the panels make is billed at a predictable rate as low as $0.10 per kWh, your full 25-year rate schedule is set in your contract before you sign, and a battery is included. Solar lease cost per month in Illinois walks through the numbers. If money's tight, check Illinois Solar for All first.
Thinking about leaving propane behind? Send me last winter's propane delivery tickets and a recent Ameren or ComEd bill. I'll show you your real cost per unit of heat, what a heat pump would add to your electric bill, and whether solar makes sense on top. Call (618) 217-2001, run your numbers through the savings calculator, or get in touch here. For the rest of this winter's outlook, see the Illinois winter heating bill forecast and the current Ameren rates and ComEd rates.
Sources
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Weekly Illinois Propane Residential Price (weekly heating-season series, through the week of Oct 5, 2026), released Oct 7, 2026 — https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/hist/LeafHandler.ashx?n=PET&s=W_EPLLPA_PRS_SIL_DPG&f=W
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Heating Oil and Propane Update (prices exclude taxes; collected October through March) — https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/heatingoilpropane/
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Short-Term Energy Outlook, Table WF01 (Midwest propane households: 528.9 gal heating, 112.4 gal non-heating, $2.036/gal, winter 2026–27 forecast), October 2026 — https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/xls/wf01.xlsx
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, British thermal units (propane: 1 gallon = 91,452 Btu) — https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/units-and-calculators/british-thermal-units.php
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Energy conversion calculators (1 kWh = 3,412 Btu) — https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/units-and-calculators/energy-conversion-calculators.php
- Plug In Illinois, Price to Compare, Ameren Illinois (10.441¢ first 800 kWh, 8.262¢ above, Oct 1, 2026 – May 31, 2027) — https://plugin.illinois.gov/understanding-the-price-to-compare/price-to-compare-ameren-illinois.html
- Plug In Illinois, Price to Compare, ComEd (10.103¢, Oct 1, 2026 – May 31, 2027) — https://plugin.illinois.gov/understanding-the-price-to-compare/price-to-compare-comed.html
- Ameren Illinois, Rate PBR-R Appendix (DS-1 non-summer delivery 4.572¢ first 800 kWh, 2.427¢ above) — https://www.ameren.com/-/media/rates/illinois/residential/electric-rates/distribution-delivery/aiel8rtpbrr08282025.ashx
- ComEd, A Guide to the Retail Customer's Billed Delivery Service Charges, charges beginning with April 2026 bills (6.333¢ standard vs 3.215¢ electric space heat, single-family) — https://www.comed.com/cdn/assets/v3/assets/blt3ebb3fed6084be2a/blt7904befea93c3525/6a74ab1af8608b565710881f/A_Guide_to_the_Retail_Customer_s_Billed_Delivery_Service_Charges.pdf
- ComEd Go Electric, Savings Calculator notes (space heat rate requires all-electric heating, including backup) — https://goelectric.comed.com/savings-calculator/
- Ameren Illinois Energy Efficiency, Switch from Propane to Electric (Home Efficiency Income Qualified initiative; eligibility and no-cost upgrades) — https://amerenillinoissavings.com/residential/energy-efficiency-home-upgrades/switch-from-propane-to-electric/
- Ameren Illinois Energy Efficiency, HVAC and Water Heating Discounts (ducted air source heat pump $900; ductless $630) — https://amerenillinoissavings.com/residential/products-discounts-and-rebates/hvac-and-water-heating-discounts/
- ComEd, Home Energy Rebates customer guide, September 2025 update (heat pump discounts up to $2,000) — https://www.comed.com/cdn/assets/v3/assets/blt3ebb3fed6084be2a/bltb8206206cff6f9c9/68bef7975c76c05195ee2699/2025_HHC_Customer_Guide_V3_September_Update.pdf
- ENERGY STAR, Version 6.2 Heat Pump Specification (cold climate: COP ≥ 1.75 at 5°F), March 2025 — https://www.energystar.gov/sites/default/files/2025-04/ENERGY%20STAR%20Version%206.2%20Heat%20Pump%20Specification%20Rev.%20March%202025.pdf
- Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, DOE Cold Climate Heat Pump Challenge field validation (PNNL-37127), January 2025 — https://www.pnnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_reports/PNNL-37127.pdf
- IRS, FAQs for modification of sections 25C, 25D and others under Public Law 119-21 (25C not allowed for property placed in service after Dec 31, 2025), Aug 21, 2025 — https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/faqs-for-modification-of-sections-25c-25d-25e-30c-30d-45l-45w-and-179d-under-public-law-119-21-139-stat-72-july-4-2025-commonly-known-as-the-one-big-beautiful-bill-obbb
- IRS, Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (30% of qualified expenses; $2,000 a year for heat pumps) — https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/energy-efficient-home-improvement-credit
- Illinois DCEO, LIHEAP How to Apply (Oct 1, 2026 priority window includes households with less than 25% in their propane tank; others Nov 1, 2026) — https://dceo.illinois.gov/communityservices/utilitybillassistance/howtoapply.html
- Illinois EPA, Energy Rebates (HEAR application not yet processed by USDOE; no retroactive rebates) — https://epa.illinois.gov/topics/energy/energy-rebates.html
- RMI, Five policies to lower heating bills and accelerate heat pump adoption in Illinois, March 20, 2026 — https://rmi.org/resources/five-policies-to-lower-heating-bills-and-accelerate-heat-pump-adoption-in-illinois/



