Is Homefield Energy Cheaper Than Ameren? 245 of 260 Illinois Town Power Deals Cost More Than the Utility Rate
Probably not, and it's not close. As of September 15, 2026, the Illinois Commerce Commission's own list shows 260 municipal aggregation deals in Ameren Illinois territory with a current price, and 245 of them charge more than Ameren's price to compare of 11.326¢ per kWh (the summer rate, June 1 through September 30, 2026). Homefield Energy holds 188 of those 260 contracts. Only 15 towns beat the utility.
I sell solar across central and southern Illinois, so I look at a lot of Ameren bills at kitchen tables. A surprising number of those bills show a supplier the homeowner doesn't remember choosing. Usually they didn't. Their town chose it for them in a program called municipal aggregation, and most of them assume the town got a deal. The state's list says otherwise, and I'd rather you see the numbers than take my word for it.
The numbers, straight from the state's list
The Citizens Utility Board published an analysis of these deals on August 26 and found more than nine in ten Ameren-territory offers were money-losers. I pulled the same ICC list myself on September 15 and dropped every row whose posted term had already ended, so the figures below are the deals actually priced today.
| What the ICC list shows (Sept 15, 2026) | Ameren Illinois territory | ComEd territory |
|---|---|---|
| Utility price to compare (June 1–Sept 30, 2026) | 11.326¢/kWh | 10.399¢/kWh |
| Aggregation deals with a current price | 260 | 165 |
| Deals priced above the utility | 245 | 6 (another 10 sit at 10.40¢, a thousandth of a cent over) |
| Deals priced below the utility | 15 | 81 |
| Deals contractually matched to the utility price | 0 | 68 |
| Average markup on the deals that cost more | ≈ 0.79¢/kWh | ≈ 0.32¢/kWh (the 6) |
| Highest rate on the list | 13.529¢ (Vermilion County) | 10.90¢ (Lake Zurich, Riverside) |
| Lowest rate on the list | 9.999¢ (Canton) | 7.591¢ (West Brooklyn) |
| Dominant supplier | Homefield Energy, 188 of 260 | MC Squared Energy Services, 125 of 165 |
| Most common term end | May 31, 2027 (184 deals) | Sept 30, 2027, Sept 30, 2028 and May 31, 2028 (19 each) |
Two things jump out. First, the ComEd side mostly works. Sixty-eight northern Illinois towns wrote their contracts to track ComEd's price, and 81 more are priced under it. Second, the Ameren side is where the money leaks, and it leaks unevenly. Of the 245 deals above the utility, 121 are within half a cent, which barely matters. But 101 towns are at 12¢ or more, and 49 of them are at 13¢ or higher, which is close to two cents over Ameren for every kilowatt-hour.
Your town, if you're in my part of the state
Here's the current-term row for the places I actually drive to. Rates are cents per kWh from the ICC list; the "extra per month" column is my estimate at 1,000 kWh, which is a normal summer month for a family home around here.
| Community | Supplier | Aggregation rate | vs. Ameren 11.326¢ | Est. extra at 1,000 kWh/mo | Price runs through |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peoria, Peoria County, Washington, Morton, Peoria Heights, West Peoria | Homefield Energy | 13.29¢ | +1.96¢ | ≈ $20 | June 30, 2027 |
| Belleville | Homefield Energy | 13.09¢ | +1.76¢ | ≈ $18 | May 31, 2027 |
| Shiloh, Glen Carbon, Jerseyville | Homefield Energy | 13.09¢ | +1.76¢ | ≈ $18 | June 30, 2027 |
| Centralia | Homefield Energy | 13.09¢ | +1.76¢ | ≈ $18 | June 30, 2027 |
| Alton, East Alton, Wood River, Roxana, Hartford | Homefield Energy | 13.19¢ | +1.86¢ | ≈ $19 | May–June 2027 |
| Trenton | Homefield Energy | 13.49¢ | +2.16¢ | ≈ $22 | May 31, 2027 |
| Godfrey, Troy, Bethalto | Homefield Energy | 12.99¢ | +1.66¢ | ≈ $17 | May–June 2027 |
| Pekin, Champaign County, Mahomet | Direct Energy | 12.91¢ | +1.58¢ | ≈ $16 | May 31, 2027 |
| Urbana | Direct Energy | 12.88¢ | +1.55¢ | ≈ $16 | May 31, 2027 |
| Bloomington, Normal, Galesburg, Lincoln | Direct Energy | 12.76¢ | +1.43¢ | ≈ $14 | Aug 31, 2027 |
| Millstadt | Homefield Energy | 12.095¢ | +0.77¢ | ≈ $8 | May 31, 2027 |
| Swansea | Constellation | 11.997¢ | +0.67¢ | ≈ $7 | May 31, 2027 |
| Cahokia Heights | Homefield Energy | 11.99¢ | +0.66¢ | ≈ $7 | May 31, 2027 |
| Danville | Constellation | 11.695¢ | +0.37¢ | ≈ $4 | May 31, 2027 |
| Carbondale, Marion, Mt. Vernon, West Frankfort, Du Quoin, Murphysboro, Chester, Sparta, Nashville, Dupo | Homefield Energy | 11.378¢ | +0.05¢ | ≈ $0.50 | May 31, 2027 |
| Champaign | Homefield Energy | 10.899¢ | −0.43¢ | saves ≈ $4 | May 1, 2027 |
| Edwardsville | Direct Energy | 10.82¢ | −0.51¢ | saves ≈ $5 | June 30, 2027 |
| East St. Louis | Homefield Energy | 10.75¢ | −0.58¢ | saves ≈ $6 | May 31, 2027 |
| Quincy, Taylorville | Homefield Energy | 10.49¢ | −0.84¢ | saves ≈ $8 | May 1, 2027 |
| Canton | Constellation | 9.999¢ | −1.33¢ | saves ≈ $13 | June 30, 2027 |
A few towns you might expect are missing on purpose. O'Fallon, Granite City, Maryville, Jacksonville and East Peoria show a posted term that ended in May or June 2026, so the list's price for them is stale; call your city hall for the renewed rate. Decatur's program expired in 2021, Effingham's, Mattoon's and Charleston's in December 2025, and Columbia's in June 2025. Springfield isn't on the list because CWLP is a city utility, not Ameren. Collinsville, Fairview Heights, Highland and Waterloo have no aggregation program listed at all.
Notice who's on the wrong end. Edwardsville, ten minutes from Glen Carbon, pays 10.82¢ while Glen Carbon pays 13.09¢. Same utility, same wires, same weather. The difference is entirely the contract the village signed and when it signed it.
Why a deal that was good in 2024 is bad in 2026
Nobody in these towns did anything dumb. The deals were mostly signed when Ameren's price to compare was higher than the aggregation rate, and a fixed 13.29¢ looked like protection. Then the utility's price moved. Ameren's supply price is set through state-run auctions and resets twice a year, and the summer 2026 price of 11.326¢ landed below what a lot of towns had locked in through mid-2027.
That's the structural problem with a fixed aggregation rate. Your town bets on a number for two or three years, and the utility gets to change its number every June and October. Sometimes the town wins that bet. This cycle, in Ameren territory, it mostly lost.
I'd also point out that CUB found closer to the opposite in September 2023, when 157 of the 293 active Ameren-territory offers (54%) were beating the utility price. Both reads were right for their moment. The lesson isn't "aggregation is a scam." It's that the deal has an expiration date and a comparison price, and you have to check both every year.
October 1 is when this gets more expensive
Here's the part that makes me want to publish this now rather than in the spring.
Ameren's 11.326¢ price expires September 30. A new non-summer price takes over October 1 and runs through May 2027. As of today the October figure hasn't been posted, so I can't tell you what it is. What I can tell you is that last cycle's non-summer Ameren price was 8.402¢ from October through December 2025 and 8.769¢ from January through May 2026, and the October reset came in below the summer price in each of the last two years. (It went the other way in 2022 and 2023, so this is a pattern, not a rule.)
If October lands anywhere near last winter's 8.769¢, a Peoria household locked at 13.29¢ until June 30, 2027 would be paying an estimated 4.5¢ more per kilowatt-hour than a neighbor on plain Ameren supply, all winter. On an 800 kWh January that's about $36 in one month. The September gap in the table above may be the smallest that gap will be until next summer.
Check the state's price-to-compare page the first week of October, then redo the subtraction for your town. It takes two minutes.
How to opt out
The supplier had to mail you an opt-out notice when the program started; sending that back is how you stay on Ameren from day one. If that window is long gone, you can still leave. CUB's August review says that if your aggregation rate costs more than the utility's supply price, you can opt out and return to default utility service without paying an exit fee. The ICC's own aggregation page says suppliers are prohibited from applying early termination fees or penalties to residential customers who go back to the utility, and the statute behind that (220 ILCS 5/16-119) has given residential customers the right to terminate a supplier contract at any time without termination fees or penalties since January 1, 2020. I walked through the switch-back steps and phone numbers in the alternative supplier post.
Expect one or two billing cycles before the change shows up, because it takes effect at a meter read. Nothing about delivery changes. Ameren still owns the wires, still reads the meter, and still takes the outage call, which is why the delivery half of your bill looks identical no matter whose name is on the supply line. If you're not sure how the supply and delivery halves fit together, the price-to-compare explainer lays it out with a real bill.
One honest caveat in the other direction: if your town is one of the 15 that beat Ameren, stay put through September 30, then look again in October. And if you're in a ComEd town on a "ComEd Match" contract, there's nothing to do; you're paying the utility price by design.
What this has to do with solar
I'll be straight about my angle. Every option above, aggregation or plain Ameren, still buys electricity at whatever the market sets that season. The town's contract just decides who sets it.
A solar lease is the one version of this where the rate schedule is written into your own contract for 25 years before you sign, at a rate as low as $0.10/kWh for the power the panels make. That's an estimate until someone has looked at your roof and your usage, and it only covers the supply half of the bill, not delivery. But it's the only path I know of where the October reset stops being your problem. If you want to see what that looks like for your house, the savings calculator runs the estimate for free, or you can read the current Ameren rate breakdown first.
Either way, pull your bill tonight and find the supply line. If it says Homefield Energy and you live in Peoria or Belleville, you now know what it's costing you.
Questions about your town's row, or want a second set of eyes on the bill? Call me at (618) 217-2001 or use the contact page. All savings figures on this page are estimates.
Sources
- Illinois Commerce Commission, Plug In Illinois — Municipal Aggregation Communities list (supplier, rate, term, territory per community; pulled September 15, 2026): https://plugin.illinois.gov/municipal-aggregation/municipal-aggregation-list.html
- Illinois Commerce Commission, Plug In Illinois — Price to Compare, Ameren Illinois (11.326¢/kWh, June 1–September 30, 2026): https://plugin.illinois.gov/understanding-the-price-to-compare/price-to-compare-ameren-illinois.html
- Illinois Commerce Commission, Plug In Illinois — Price to Compare, ComEd (10.399¢/kWh, June 1–September 30, 2026): https://plugin.illinois.gov/understanding-the-price-to-compare/price-to-compare-comed.html
- Illinois Commerce Commission, Plug In Illinois — Municipal Aggregation overview and opt-out notice process: https://plugin.illinois.gov/municipal-aggregation.html
- Illinois Commerce Commission — Historical Prices to Compare PDF (Ameren 8.402¢ Oct–Dec 2025, 8.769¢ Jan–May 2026; updated through September 2026): https://icc.illinois.gov/downloads/public/pluginillinois/HistoricalPriceToCompare.pdf
- 220 ILCS 5/16-119 — right to terminate a supplier contract without fees, effective January 1, 2020 (P.A. 101-590): https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/fulltext.asp?DocName=022000050K16-119
- Citizens Utility Board — "Don't assume your town's municipal aggregation deal will save you money" (August 26, 2026): https://www.citizensutilityboard.org/blog/2026/08/26/cub-analysis-dont-assume-your-towns-municipal-aggregation-deal-will-save-you-money/
- Citizens Utility Board — "Most municipal aggregation offers saving money, but changes on horizon" (September 22, 2023): https://www.citizensutilityboard.org/blog/2023/09/22/special-report-most-municipal-aggregation-saving-money-but-changes-on-horizon/



