Nicor Gas Rate Settlement Approved: The $15 Customer Charge Starts Nov. 16, but Winter Bills Still Rise
The average Nicor Gas home will pay about $2.21 a month more. The Illinois Commerce Commission approved a settlement on October 15, 2026 that strikes $139.2 million, roughly 63%, from Nicor's $221 million rate request, leaving an increase of about $82 million. The bigger change for your bill is how the money gets collected. The fixed monthly customer charge falls from $21.30 to $15.00 on November 16, and the rest moves onto the part of the bill you pay per therm. Summer bills go down. Winter bills go up by more than the $2.21 headline for most houses that heat with gas.
Nicor delivers gas to 2.3 million customers across northern Illinois. I sell solar here, and the gas bill is the one people hand me from now until March. So here's what got approved, what it means for a July bill versus a January bill, and the one number Nicor hasn't published yet.
Key facts: the Nicor Gas settlement
| Item | Figure | Source / date |
|---|---|---|
| Decision | Settlement approved by the Illinois Commerce Commission, Docket No. 26-0099 | ICC, Oct 15, 2026 |
| Requested increase | About $221 million (14.5% over current rates) | ICC; Illinois Attorney General |
| Amount cut | $139.2 million, about 63% | ICC, Oct 15, 2026 |
| Approved increase | About $82 million ($221M minus $139.2M; CUB, a party to the case, puts it at $81.6M) | ICC figures, my arithmetic |
| Average residential impact | About $2.21 a month, 2.49% of the total annual bill | Nicor Gas, rate request page |
| Monthly customer charge | $21.30 now → $15.00 | ICC; starts Nov 16 per Attorney General and CUB |
| Distribution charge now | 24.44¢ per therm; new figure not yet posted | Nicor Rate 1, effective Sept 28, 2026 |
| Return on equity | 9.48%, down from the 10.35% Nicor requested | ICC, Oct 15, 2026 |
| Customers served | 2.3 million across northern Illinois | ICC, Oct 15, 2026 |
What the Commission approved
Nicor filed in January for about $221 million. The Attorney General's office, the Citizens Utility Board and the other parties reached a settlement, and on October 15 the Commission accepted it. In the ICC's words, the decision cuts "Nicor's initial $221 million requested increase by roughly 63 percent and approves a 9.48 percent return on equity," down from the 10.35% Nicor asked for.
Nicor also agreed to drop its appeal of last year's rate case. That 2025 order approved a $168 million increase, or 12.1%, according to the Attorney General's office.
Nicor had estimated its original request at less than $6 a month for a typical home. The settlement lands at about $2.21. That's a real cut. CUB still points out this is Nicor's sixth delivery increase since 2017, adding up to about 150%. Both things are true.
The $15 charge is the part that changes your bill
There are two delivery numbers on a Nicor residential bill. One is the customer charge, the flat amount you pay even in a month you burn nothing. The other is the distribution charge, a price per therm. (Gas supply is a third line, and it moves every month on its own.)
The settlement cuts the flat one by $6.30 a month. The total still goes up. So the per-therm charge has to rise by enough to cover the $6.30 cut and the new increase.
You can work out the size of that shift from Nicor's two published numbers:
- Average home, net: +$2.21 a month (+$26.52 a year)
- Customer charge: −$6.30 a month (−$75.60 a year)
- Usage-based delivery charges, average home: about +$8.51 a month, or about $102 a year
Nicor's two figures also tell you how big the average bill is. If $26.52 a year is 2.49% of it, the average Nicor residential bill runs about $1,065 a year, roughly $89 a month. That's my arithmetic, not a number Nicor printed.
July vs. January
Gas use swings hard by season. The federal Energy Information Administration's average Midwest gas-heated home burns about 612 therms from November through March alone, and far less in summer. The flat $6.30 cut is the same every month, but the per-therm increase follows your usage. That's why the Attorney General's office says most Nicor customers will see a monthly bill decrease during non-heat months.
Here's my estimate of how a single month changes, depending on how that month's gas use compares to the average Nicor home's monthly use. It assumes the whole increase lands on the per-therm distribution charge, and it leaves out taxes and supply prices.
| A month using… | Estimated change vs. today's rates |
|---|---|
| A quarter of the average month (summer) | about −$4.17 |
| Half the average month | about −$2.04 |
| The average month | about +$2.21 |
| Twice the average month | about +$10.72 |
| Three times the average month (deep winter) | about +$19.23 |
My take: if you're on budget billing, you'll barely notice this month to month. If you're not, December through February is where you'll see it. Pair that with supply prices, which often climb into the coldest weeks, and a January Nicor bill can be noticeably higher than the headline suggests.
Who comes out ahead
Over a full year, the line falls at about three-quarters of the average customer's gas use. Below that, the $75.60 saved on the customer charge beats the higher per-therm cost. Above it, you pay more. All of these are my estimates, built from Nicor's figures:
- A condo or small home with just a gas stove and water heater, using about a quarter of the average: roughly $50 a year less
- Half the average: roughly $25 a year less
- The average home: about $26.52 a year more
- One and a half times the average, like a large older house: roughly $78 a year more
- Double the average: roughly $129 a year more
To run your own, add up your last 12 months of therms from your bills. Once Nicor posts the new distribution charge, multiply the per-therm increase by those therms and subtract $75.60. That's your number.
Peoples Gas is next
If you're in Chicago, your gas utility is Peoples Gas, not Nicor, and its case is still open. Peoples cut its request from $202 million to $144 million on July 14, 2026, and put the typical impact at about $7 to $8 a month. The company says a Commission decision "is expected by December." I covered both cases, and what EIA expects this winter, in the Illinois winter heating bill forecast.
If this winter's bill is going to be tight
- LIHEAP opens to all eligible households November 1, after the October 1 priority window. Income limits and how to apply are in Illinois bill help and income limits.
- Nicor's low-income discount gets another look too. The ICC says the decision reinforces its 2025 directive that Nicor adjust the discount "to maintain a 3 percent energy burden" for customers who qualify.
- Winter shut-off protections begin December 1. The fall is the gap. Here's when Illinois utilities can and can't disconnect you.
- On budget billing? A settle-up month can land in the middle of winter. How Illinois budget billing settle-ups work.
What this means for a heat pump in Nicor territory
A heat pump saves the most when it lets you close the gas account, because the customer charge disappears. At $15, that's $180 a year instead of $255.60, so that part of the switch is worth about $75.60 a year less. Every therm you keep burning gets pricier, though, so the two changes partly cancel.
In my September comparison, Nicor territory was already where a heat pump had the thinnest edge over gas on running cost. Nicor's 24.44¢ distribution charge is about half of Peoples Gas's and Ameren's. I'll rerun the heat pump vs. gas furnace numbers when the new rate posts. For homes on propane, the answer is much clearer, and it's in heat pump vs. propane costs.
Where solar fits
Solar panels don't touch a gas bill. If your furnace burns gas, this settlement is your winter, and panels on the roof don't change that.
What solar does change is the other utility bill on the counter, the ComEd or Ameren one. A $0-down lease bills the power your panels make at a predictable rate as low as $0.10 per kWh, with a battery included and the full 25-year rate schedule set in your contract before you sign.
Want me to look at both bills? Send me your last Nicor bill and your last ComEd or Ameren bill. I'll show you what you pay per therm and per kWh, and which line is rising faster. Call (618) 217-2001, run your numbers through the savings calculator, or get in touch here.
Sources
- Illinois Commerce Commission, press release, "ICC approves $139 million cut to Nicor Gas rate request" (Docket No. 26-0099; $221 million request; 9.48% ROE vs. 10.35% requested; residential customer charge $21.30 to $15.00; 2.3 million customers), October 15, 2026 — https://www.icc.illinois.gov/api/web-management/documents/downloads/public/press-release/10-15-26%20Nicor%2026-0099.pdf
- Nicor Gas, 2026 Rate Request (settlement approved; average residential impact about $2.21 per month, 2.49% of the total annual bill; customer charge $21.30 to $15.00), accessed October 17, 2026 — https://www.nicorgas.com/company/rate-request.html
- Nicor Gas, Rate Request, original filing (about $221 million filed Jan. 9; typical residential increase "less than $6 per month"), accessed October 17, 2026 — https://www.nicorgas.com/pages/work-in-progress/rate-request.html
- Nicor Gas, Rate 1 Residential Service, 22nd Revised Sheet No. 10 (customer charge $21.30; distribution charge 24.44¢ per therm), effective September 28, 2026 — https://www.nicorgas.com/content/dam/southern-co-gas/nicor-gas/docs/rates-and-riders/nicor-rate-1.pdf
- Illinois Attorney General, "Attorney General Raoul announces settlement with Nicor Gas" ($221 million request, 14.5%; fixed charge to $15.00 beginning Nov. 16; non-heat-month bill decrease; 2025 order $168 million, 12.1%), September 9, 2026 — https://www.illinoisattorneygeneral.gov/news/story/attorney-general-raoul-announces-settlement-with-nicor-gas
- Citizens Utility Board (party to the case), "State regulators OK settlement in Nicor Gas rate case" ($220.8 million cut by $139 million to $81.6 million; $2.21 a month; $15 customer charge beginning Nov. 16; six delivery increases, about 150%, since 2017), October 15, 2026 — https://www.citizensutilityboard.org/blog/2026/10/15/illinois-attorney-general-announces-settlement-to-nicor-gas-rate-case/
- Peoples Gas, "Peoples Gas reduces rate request by $58 million" ($144 million; about $7 to $8 per month; decision expected by December), July 14, 2026 — https://news.peoplesgasdelivery.com/?p=839
- Peoples Gas, Natural gas rates (Rate 1 heating sales distribution $0.46583 per therm), accessed October 7, 2026 — https://www.peoplesgasdelivery.com/payment-bill/gas-rates
- Ameren Illinois, Rate GDS-1 Residential Gas Delivery Service (distribution $0.48344 per therm), effective January 16, 2026 — https://www.ameren.com/-/media/rates/illinois/residential/gas-rates/distribution-delivery/aigs18gdsc.ashx
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Short-Term Energy Outlook, Table WF01 (Midwest natural gas-heated home, 59.033 thousand cubic feet, about 612 therms, November–March 2026–27 forecast), October 2026 — https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/xls/wf01.xlsx
- Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity, LIHEAP How to Apply (October 1 priority households; November 1 all others) — https://dceo.illinois.gov/communityservices/utilitybillassistance/howtoapply.html
- Illinois Commerce Commission, Utility Energy Assistance (December 1 – March 31 winter disconnection rules) — https://www.icc.illinois.gov/consumers/utility-energy-assistance



